|
City Manager’s Column: Radium in the Water.
10-21-02
As most of you know, we have a problem with radium
in our drinking water.
This is a cause for concern, but it is not a time
for panic.
In Iowa, the Dept of Natural Resources (DNR)
contracts with the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to
enforce its standards. The current standard for radium in drinking
water is not to exceed 5 pico curies per liter for testing done over
4 straight quarters of a year.
This is a topic that has been talked about before
at public meetings. Earlier this year, I also talked about it on
Sheri Melvold's radio show on KMAQ. As of that time, no one called
City Hall to ask about what was happening or what we were doing.
The event that changed things was a letter the
Iowa DNR required us to send out. It was entitled, "Public
Notification Radium in Water Exceeds Limit." The letter
contained the DNR's wording. And, while it said that the presence of
radium "is not considered to be an immediate health risk,"
it had other language that made drinking the water seem about as bad
as smoking cigarettes.
Personally, I feel that, while the DNR's
statements about what radium can do to a person may have been
accurate in general, the letter inaccurately portrayed the situation
in Maquoketa.
This is what we know:
Two of the four wells that Maquoketa uses have
tested over the 5 pico curie standard. The results for these two
wells have ranged from 6.8 pCi/liter to 11.7 pCi/liter.
One of the wells that is over the limit is the one
near the water tower that is by the Community Center. The other one
is just north of the parking lot in 5th Ward Park.
We were not aware of it until just recently, but
these wells tested similarly as long ago as 1980. However, we have
also been told that, at about that time, the EPA was actually on the
road to relaxing the pico curie/liter standard from 5 to 20, but, in
the end, did not.
So, what has changed between the 1980s and now?
The major difference appears to be the location of where the tests
are taken.
One of the methods for addressing a radium problem
is to blend the water from wells with higher levels of radium with
the water from wells with lower levels of radium. Up until recently,
cities were allowed to test their water supplies at a location where
the water was known to have blended. In our case, the tests were
done at City Hall. The test results for City Hall showed the pico
curie level at 1.8 per liter. Compared to the maximum that is
allowed, 5, this is quite good.
But, more recently, towns have been required to
change the location of their tests to be directly out of their
wells. While it is certainly true that there are some houses that
are closer to these two wells than is City Hall, it is also true
that no one drinks directly out of either of these wells. Most of
the water that is consumed in Maquoketa is blended in our water
towers and water mains with water from all of our wells.
But still, we have to be concerned. The DNR has
given us an analogy to offer to people as an example of radium
exposure, in general. They tell us that people stand a statistical
chance of 2 in 10,000 that someone will develop cancer if they
ingest/drink the equivalent of 2 liters of water per day for 70
years. While I doubt that anyone drinks that much tap water
(considering that we also drink milk, pop, and other soft drinks)
each day, we should also pause to consider that such statistics are
most often offered in factors of "per million" rather than
"per ten thousand."
The Council's Utilities Committee is in the
process of collecting proposals from engineering firms on ideas to
correct this problem so that we can come into compliance with the
radium standard. At the same time, we have asked the various
engineering firms to consider the correction of other problems with
our water system, such as reducing the level of iron in our water.
I would anticipate that a firm will be selected
sometime in November. Most of the firms that we have talked to have
told us to expect it to take about 3-4 months for a study to be
completed. We will keep you informed along the way.
|